When you hear the words “stem cell donation” and “bone marrow donation,” you might wonder: Aren’t they the same thing? The answer is both yes and no! Both forms of donation provide the same blood-forming stem cells that can help patients fight life-threatening diseases, but the way those cells are collected is quite different. In fact, most donors today – more than 95% – give stem cells collected directly from their bloodstream, rather than marrow from their hip bone. So why are there two methods, how do they differ, and how did stem cell donation evolve over the years? Let’s take a closer look.
The stem cells that form blood and create the immune system are produced in the bone marrow and are called Hematopoietic Stem Cells. These are the cells that both processes collect. While these cells are generated in the bone marrow, some of them also circulate naturally in the bloodstream. Transplants of these cells have the power to help cure more than 75 diseases, provided there is a genetic match between the donor and the patient.
There are two possible methods of collecting these powerful cells: peripheral blood stem cell (PBSC) donation and bone marrow donation. Both methods provide the patient’s transplant team with the same hematopoietic stem cells that form blood and create the immune system.

Peripheral blood stem cell collection is done at an outpatient center, such as Gift of Life’s Adelson Collection Center, and is not a surgical procedure.

Bone marrow collection is done at a hospital setting under general anesthesia, usually in a surgical center.
Note: Marrow donation does not involve the spine; this is a common misconception.
The short answer to this is “yes” because the cells being collected are hematopoietic stem cells – the blood-forming stem cells with the capability of curing many conditions. Since they are found in several locations in the body, there are two effective methods of collecting them.
At a more medical level, the overall cellular mix of the marrow graft and the PBSC graft is not completely identical. Peripheral blood stem cell collections typically contain more T-cells, which can affect transplant outcomes, such as graft-versus-host disease (GVHD), at an individual patient level.
For many children, transplant physicians may prefer bone marrow as the source of donated stem cells because, in some studies, marrow grafts have been associated with a lower risk of some complications, such as graft-versus-host disease. This medical decision is made on an individual basis, and many factors are taken into consideration.
The transplant physician and team carefully evaluate every patient’s disease, transplant circumstances, age, and the potential risks and benefits of using either a PBSC or bone marrow transplant. Treatement is highly individualized, and there is not a single best method that works for everyone.
Marrow transplantation was first discovered in the 1950s, and peripheral blood stem cell collection was introduced in 1986 as an alternative method of obtaining these potentially curative cells. Today, well over 95% of collections are PBSC. There are a number of practical reasons this collection method has become predominant:
This makes the entire process easier to schedule quickly and less expensive to perform, as well as there being no need for donors to receive anesthesia.
For patients, there is an additional benefit: PBSC grafts typically contain a higher number of blood-forming cells needed and tend to engraft more quickly. But this advantage is usually balanced against differences in GVHD risk when the transplant center is determining the best treatment.
While PBSC has become more widely used, bone marrow is still preferred in some circumstances. Each patient’s best options for treatment are evaluated individually by their transplant physician and team.
Because bone marrow transplantation was established decades before the introduction of peripheral blood stem cell collection methods, the standard terminology has long been to say “marrow registry,” and the transplant of hematopoietic stem cells a “bone marrow transplant.”
Even as the science behind donation and transplantation has evolved, the name has stuck. While the terminology is slowly changing toward “stem cell transplant” and “stem cell registry,” “bone marrow” remains the more familiar term for now.
The first marrow registry was established in England in 1974, and over the next several decades, registries were formed around the world. The need for international cooperation led to the establishment of the World Marrow Donor Association, which now counts 103 marrow registry organizations in 61 countries.
No, these are common misconceptions, but they are completely inaccurate. No bone is removed, and the spine is not involved at all.
Marrow is a spongy tissue found inside the bones, with a large area in the iliac crest of the pelvic bone. When marrow is drawn out for transplant (using needles, no bone is removed) your body naturally replenishes what you have donated.
Similarly, when you donate stem cells via apheresis, your body will replace the stem cells back to their normal levels.
Gift of Life does not determine which donation method is best for the patient, nor does the donor have a choice of the method to be used. The patient’s transplant team and physician choose the type of collection needed to provide the best results for their patient’s unique condition and circumstances.
Ultimately, whether a patient receives a transplant using cells collected from the bloodstream or directly from the bone marrow, the goal is the same: to provide healthy blood-forming stem cells that can give a patient a chance at a cure. The patient’s transplant team determines which collection method is best based on the patient’s individual needs, while donors can feel confident knowing that their donated cells will naturally be replenished. No matter how the cells are collected, becoming a donor can be a life-changing act that gives someone in need a second chance at life. Click here if you are not yet on the registry and would like to order a swab kit.